Five Top Reasons Mediation Fails
May 9, 2023

Mediation is a popular alternative to traditional litigation, allowing parties to resolve disputes in a non-adversarial, cost-effective, and confidential manner. However, like any other process, mediation can sometimes fail. In this blog post, we will discuss the top reasons why mediation can fail and offer solutions to prevent it.


Lack of Preparation: One of the main reasons why mediation can fail is a lack of preparation. Parties may come to mediation unprepared, without a clear understanding of their needs and interests, or without the necessary documentation to support their positions. The solution is to ensure that parties are well-prepared and have all the information they need to make informed decisions. Mediators can provide parties with a checklist of documents and information needed, as well as offer guidance on how to prepare for mediation.


Unrealistic Expectations: Another common reason why mediation can fail is unrealistic expectations. Parties may come to mediation expecting a complete resolution of all their issues or a one-sided outcome. The solution is to manage expectations and help parties understand that mediation is a collaborative process that requires compromise and negotiation. Mediators can help parties set realistic goals and expectations for the mediation process.


Lack of Trust: A lack of trust between parties can also cause mediation to fail. Parties may be unwilling to share information or may be suspicious of the other party's motives. The solution is to build trust and rapport between parties. Mediators can help parties establish a relationship of trust and respect by setting ground rules for communication, ensuring that both parties have an opportunity to speak, and using active listening and empathic communication.


Failure to Communicate: Effective communication is essential to the success of mediation. If parties are unable to communicate effectively, mediation may fail. The solution is to ensure that parties have the necessary communication skills to participate in mediation. Mediators can provide guidance on effective communication techniques, such as active listening, reframing, and summarizing.


Inflexibility: Finally, inflexibility can also cause mediation to fail. Parties may be unwilling to consider alternative solutions or may be stuck in a rigid position. The solution is to encourage flexibility and creativity. Mediators can help parties brainstorm creative solutions and evaluate the pros and cons of each option. Mediators can also suggest compromises that may not have been considered before.


By addressing these issues and working collaboratively, parties can increase the likelihood of success in mediation. If you are considering mediation as a way to resolve a dispute, be sure to choose a skilled and experienced mediator who can help you navigate the process effectively.


This blog post was written by Chelle Hendershot, Registered Mediator, Hope For Our Future, LLC. This blog is not intended to be legal advice or a solicitation for services. It is an advertisement.


Copyright © 2023 Hope For Our Future, LLC. All rights reserved. This blog post may be shared, copied, and distributed in its entirety for non-commercial purposes, provided that proper attribution is given, and no modifications are made to the original work.

Related Post

8 Strategies for Effective Communication with a Guardian ad Litem in Indiana

March 21, 2025
When a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) is appointed in an Indiana family law case, their primary role is to represent the best interests of the child. Communicating effectively with the GAL can help ensure they have the information needed to make informed recommendations to the court. Here are eight strategies to facilitate positive and productive communication with a GAL. 1. Understand the GAL’s Role A GAL is a neutral party assigned to investigate and advocate for the child's best interests. They do not represent either parent and do not make final legal decisions. Understanding their responsibilities will help you engage with them appropriately. 2. Be Honest and Transparent Honesty is crucial when communicating with a GAL. Provide truthful and complete information about your situation, parenting abilities, and any concerns regarding the child’s well-being. Misrepresenting facts can damage credibility and impact the case. 3. Keep the Focus on Your Child When speaking with a GAL, always center discussions on your child’s needs and best interests. Avoid negative comments about the other parent and instead highlight how your parenting supports your child’s emotional and physical well-being. 4. Respond Promptly to Requests A GAL may request documents, records, or interviews to assess the family situation. Timely responses demonstrate cooperation and a willingness to facilitate the investigation process. 5. Provide Organized and Relevant Information If submitting documentation or evidence, ensure it is well-organized and directly relevant to your case. This might include school records, medical reports, or a parenting schedule that supports your claims. 6. Maintain Professional and Respectful Communication Whether meeting in person, speaking over the phone, or sending emails, always be respectful and professional in your tone. Avoid emotional outbursts or confrontational language, as a GAL’s impression of your behavior can influence their recommendations. 7. Follow Court Orders and Parenting Plans Adhering to court-ordered parenting plans and demonstrating responsible co-parenting will reflect positively in a GAL’s assessment. If you encounter issues with compliance, communicate these concerns calmly and factually. 8. Ask Questions When Necessary If you are unsure about any aspect of the GAL’s role or investigation, don’t hesitate to ask for clarification. Understanding the process will help you engage more effectively and reduce unnecessary stress. By following these strategies, you can build a cooperative relationship with the Guardian ad Litem and help them make well-informed recommendations that serve your child’s best interests. Effective communication and a child-centered approach will contribute to a fair and positive outcome in your case. This post was written by Chelle Hendershot, who is a dedicated Mediator and Parenting Coordinator at Hope For Our Future, LLC, with a passion for helping individuals and families navigate through life's most challenging moments. This post is not intended to be legal advice and is for marketing purposes only. Copyright © 2025 Hope For Our Future, LLC. All rights reserved. This blog post may be shared, copied, and distributed in its entirety for non-commercial purposes, provided that proper attribution is given, and no modifications are made to the original work.

Ten Tips for Selecting a Parenting Coordinator

March 21, 2025
Choosing the right parenting coordinator (PC) is an important decision that can significantly impact your co-parenting relationship and your child’s well-being. A PC helps facilitate communication, resolve disputes, and ensure that parenting agreements are followed. Here are ten key tips to help you select the best parenting coordinator for your family’s needs. 1. Understand the Role of a Parenting Coordinator Before selecting a PC, ensure you fully understand their role. A PC is a neutral third party who assists parents in managing conflicts, clarifying agreements, and improving communication—not a legal advocate or therapist. 2. Look for Proper Credentials A qualified PC should have relevant experience in family law, mediation, or mental health. Check their education, certifications, and professional background to ensure they have the expertise necessary to handle parenting disputes effectively. 3. Consider Their Experience Experience matters when dealing with high-conflict co-parenting situations. Look for a PC with a strong track record of working with families in similar circumstances. Ask about their previous cases and success in resolving disputes. 4. Assess Their Conflict Resolution Style Every PC has a different approach to resolving disputes. Some may take a more facilitative role, while others are more directive. Determine which style aligns best with your situation and co-parenting dynamic. 5. Check for Impartiality A good PC should remain neutral and not favor one parent over the other. During the selection process, assess whether the PC demonstrates fairness and an ability to handle conflicts without bias. 6. Seek Recommendations and Reviews Ask family law attorneys, mediators, or other parents for recommendations. Online reviews and testimonials can also provide insight into a PC’s effectiveness and reputation. 7. Evaluate Their Communication Skills Your PC should be able to communicate clearly, professionally, and with empathy. Effective communication is crucial for managing conflicts and ensuring both parents understand their roles and responsibilities. 8. Understand Their Fees and Payment Structure PC services come at a cost, and their fees vary depending on experience and location. Get a clear understanding of their pricing, retainer requirements, and payment structure before making a decision. 9. Confirm Their Availability Some PCs have heavy caseloads and may not be readily available when you need them. Ask about their availability and response times to ensure they can provide timely assistance when issues arise. 10. Trust Your Instincts Ultimately, you should feel comfortable with your PC choice. If you have any doubts or feel uneasy about a particular candidate, trust your instincts and continue your search until you find the right fit. Selecting the right parenting coordinator can make co-parenting smoother and less stressful. By considering these ten factors, you can find a PC who will support your family’s needs and help create a healthier environment for your child. This post was written by Chelle Hendershot, who is a dedicated Mediator and Parenting Coordinator at Hope For Our Future, LLC, with a passion for helping individuals and families navigate through life's most challenging moments. This post is not intended to be legal advice and is for marketing purposes only. Copyright © 2025 Hope For Our Future, LLC. All rights reserved. This blog post may be shared, copied, and distributed in its entirety for non-commercial purposes, provided that proper attribution is given, and no modifications are made to the original work.
Share by: